What Six Drafts of a Five-Minute Story Taught Me

As a product manager at Wealthsimple, I often need to explain complex financial processes to people with different levels of familiarity with them. The challenge is deciding what context they need, which details matter, and how to communicate them clearly.

I encountered a similar challenge in a very different setting: Storytelling Level 1 at Magnet Theater in New York City. Over six weeks, we developed personal stories, received feedback, and prepared for a five-minute showcase.

I chose a story about a college friendship. Getting it ready took six drafts, mostly spent deciding what belonged, what needed more explanation, and what I could leave out.

Deciding what belonged

My first draft followed the friendship from meeting in college to reconnecting years later. I had plenty of memories to draw from, but struggled to decide which ones belonged in the story.

As I edited, I considered two directions: how we became friends or how the friendship lasted over time. Each required different moments.

I eventually chose to focus on how the friendship began. Leaving out the later years gave me more room to explore the moments that brought us closer.

Hearing what was missing

When I shared my first draft in class, people enjoyed the details. They could picture the places and follow the things we did together.

But they wanted to know more about how I felt.

I’d described what happened without always explaining why those experiences mattered. I knew what each memory meant to me, but couldn’t assume the audience did.

In later drafts, I gave more space to my reactions: what surprised me, what made me nervous, and what made me feel comfortable in the friendship. Those details helped the audience understand why I’d chosen to tell this story.

Leaving room to tell it

Our class discussions also emphasized the importance of slowing down and giving the audience time to absorb what we’d shared. That’s difficult when you’re trying to fit years of memories into five minutes.

With fewer moments to cover, I could spend more time in each scene, pause after a line, and let people take it in before moving on.

I realized that fitting all the words into five minutes wasn’t the same as giving myself enough room to tell the story.

If you’re curious how those six drafts came together, you can watch my final showcase performance here.

Bringing it back to product

At the Women in Product conference, I learned about a communication framework that encourages you to consider what you want your audience to know, feel, and do. I later wrote about it in my conference takeaways.

My storytelling experience gave me a better appreciation for the “feel” part. I’d shared what happened, but hadn’t fully conveyed why those moments mattered to me. The feedback helped me recognize the importance of sharing my perspective rather than assuming the audience would understand it.

The same principle applies at work, where communication often needs to lead to action. Before your next meeting, ask yourself: What do people need to know? Why should they care? And what are you asking them to do?

Scroll to Top